Transatlantic - SMPTe

"Grade A prog rock!"

Being a moderate-to-HUGE fan of all the musicians involved (from Spock's Beard, Flower Kings, Dream Theater, and Marillion), I knew this was something I had to pick up. I was absolutely blown away! This entire album simply oozes excellent musicianship out of every pore.

SMPTe is a fine homage to the progressive greats of the past -- you know 'em, Genesis, Yes, ELP...all those folks. Indeed, it does sound a _little_ derivative in parts... but the songs are so excitingly arranged and performed that it's less deleterious than it could be. Despite Mike Portnoy's (drummer, Dream Theater), there's absolutely no metal present in this album. He proves that he's a very versatile drummer capable of playing any kind of song. This is definitely rock... however, because of Neal Morse (head honcho from Spock's Beard), there's a pop element present in vocal melodies unusually catchy and "light."

Of course, this album is bound to offend some people. There are those that think only the 70s prog bands are prog, and therefore anything coming afterward is not prog and is automatically awful. If that's you, don't buy this. There's also those that think prog shouldn't have a trace of pop melodic craftsmanship or charm. With TransAtlantic's pop-like vocal melodies and harmonies, you'll also hate this, so stay away.

This is some of the best progressive rock I've heard in years...a solid digression from "try-hard" prog that just doesn't quite cut it. The 30 minute masterpiece "All Of The Above" alone warrants purchasing this album. It's one of the best prog epics in decades! Recurring musical themes, topnotch musicianship, great melodies and arrangements. Also, don't be fooled by the fact that there are only five songs - this CD clocks in at 77 minutes. Just like the good ol' days, huh?

Another merit of this album that isn't so obvious is that it may lead you to some great bands. For example if you're a Flower Kings fan picking this up because of Stolt's involvement, you may go on to explore Neal Morse's band Spock's Beard. There's all kinds of opportunities here! Buy this...it's a little more old-fashioned than the contemporary progressive music scene, but the music is great, and that's what matters.