Talking about strange and/or wonderful sounds. Prog. Death Metal. Krautrock. Avant-garde. Jazz. Classical. Pop. AND MORE!
Monday, November 28, 2011
SITE UPDATE: Almost 100 reviews!
Importing old reviews is going pretty well, although we encountered a delay over the last weekend. Even so, we are up to nearly 100 reviews of various awesome stuff. MORE TO COME.
MUSIC REVIEW: Marillion - Afraid of Sunlight
"My favorite Marillion album."
This is Marillion's stunning album about the trials and tribulations of a life in the camera's eye and the price of fame. Lots of variety, but it never drifts away from the classic Hogarth-Marillion sound - that is, lush and atmospheric arrangements, swells of emotion, and of course, awesome guitar solos from Rothery. The band's command of its vast, ever-expanding musical vocabulary is so complete, and its sense of purpose so clear, that I've come to realize that Marillion is able to realize practically any direction it wishes to go.
Afraid of Sunlight is nothing like the to the grand, emotionally wrenching big-hearted rock of which mastered with Brave, and nothing like the pop-inflected Holidays In Eden. Afraid of Sunlight is minimalistic, heavy with keyboards, and relatively hookless. The album and introspective, atmospheric, moody, with progressions that are hard to grasp. But at the same time, it's instantly enjoyable. The album encapsulates the sensitivity and the beauty of Marillion better than ever. If I had to complain, it would be that the album is mostly lugubrious through and through, with no uplifting finale. Even Brave seemed to have a happy ending!
But whatever, right? This is Hogarth-Marillion's crowning achievement in terms of songwriting and musicality.
Labels:
concept album,
marillion,
neo-prog,
Steve Hogarth
MUSIC REVIEW: Marillion - Brave
"Probably Marillion's most ambitious work."
It was fifteen months of work that led to the completion of this record, which is in many ways the most 'progressive' thing the band has done. It is the touching story of a disillusioned young girl who runs away from home, attempts suicide, gets picked up by the police, and learns a thing or two about life and love. The story is told through a non-linear approach with intermittent flashbacks establishing the shattered emotional state of the story's protagonist.
After dabbling with pop for Holidays In Eden, the band headed in a challenging art-rock direction for this release, the most challenging of the Marillion catalogue (from Fish or Hogarth eras). The album features several moments of subtle beauty, emotion tumult, and brash hard-rock (some of the more audacious Marillion songs are on this album). The production is subtle and the arrangements are richly textured. Brave's music is not complicated, but it is densely layered with myriad sounds (more so than any other Marillion album).
For this reason, the album is only truly appreciated at high volume levels or with headphones. For instance, the lengthy instrumental passage on the 12 minute "Goodbye to All That" appears meandering, but headphones reveal considerable depth and ingenuity in the composition. The band adds a quick note in the liner notes, "Play it loud and with the lights off." This is definitely a must (although a candle might be handy so you can read the lyrics - it will still preserve the mood). Even saying that, I think the dynamic range of this album is just too extreme. Some parts are so quiet as to be nearly inaudible if you are listening at a "regular" volume. That's annoying, but I don't think it's a fair criticism in and of itself, because Marillion wasn't intending this to be for casual listening. Basically, it means you can't really listen to this album in the car without a lot of fiddling with the volume.
This is a wonderful album. Certainly one of the better discs from the Hogarth days.
Labels:
concept album,
marillion,
neo-prog,
Steve Hogarth
FILM REVIEW: Gladiator
"Well, there is a really cool chariot battle!"
Gladiator has somehow garnered adulation. It snagged the Oscar for Best Picture, which I find interesting but the Academy Awards have generally followed a logic I cannot grasp. It made lots of money, and collected a lot of critical acclaim. But even after watching it (twice), I steadfastly stick to my conclusion that Gladiator is not a great movie...not even a good one.
Gladiator holds promise for a heroic story with a liberal dosing of Classical-Era battles. In the end, I am left with a feeling that the film is a blatant retread of Braveheart and other more successful varieties of the "hero fighting for freedom and revenge" plot. Our hero, Maximus, spouts several turgid speeches that sound like Braveheart-lite, and his lack of emotional power render his recitations tepid and uninspiring. Maximus' forgettable dearth of emotionalized feeling when his family is mercilessly slaughtered is really pathetic. Crowe's entire role is too halfhearted (he won the Best Actor Oscar!), helped little by the cheesy script. Don't even get me started on the implicit affection between Maximus and the emperor's sister, which was so contrived as to be painful.
The battle scenes are ambitious in their orchestration, but ultimately they are filmed poorly thanks to erratic camera movement that forsake clarity or the exhilarating involvement of, say, Saving Private Ryan, where the chaos is internalized with the camera technique. Admittedly, the chariot battle is stunning, with its genuine sense of urgency that the filmmakers captured here. But why didn't they do it for the rest of the movie? It doesn't help that the different battles seem like disparate events unforgivingly adhered to an existing story line to add violent physical conflict. Like when he fights while surrounded by tigers, it doesn't seem cool or interesting, it just seems like they said, "It would be cool if there were TIGERS in this movie!" What Maximus is fighting for becomes unclear amidst the series of battles, which lack fiery emotional intensity that SHOULD be present when someone is fighting for freedom and revenege. One area that deserves accolade is the incredible sound. All around, you can hear arrows whiz by, the cacophony of clashing steel, and anguished screams. Very impressive!
And then comes the big kick in the face: the woeful anticlimax. I won't go into detail, but prepare to be disappointed. Suffice to say, Maximus becomes a martyr, but what did he accomplish? Bad, regurgitated speeches? Passionless action? Great work!
Gladiator may have been a better movie if it had been thirty minutes shorter, cut out the sordid insinuations of romance, and had more chariot battles. But when you're making a big Hollywood blockbuster, you've gotta have reams of dross (cheesiness, lame insinuated love interest) to guarantee it sells.
Labels:
Gladiator,
historical epic,
ridley scott,
russell crowe
FILM REVIEW: Crash
"Well made, interesting premise -- but execution falls flat."
This movie always appealed to me because critics said it was "gross" and I like Cronenberg and James Spader. Crash has been derided for gratuitous sexuality and the lack of a conventional story arc. But beneath the "repelling" qualities is a compelling movie that sadly suffers from a few artistic excesses that hurt the experience. This film is definitely unusual and weirdly fascinating (and certainly disturbing at times). The amort color scheme (think noirish and dreamy) augments the passionless nature of the characters, who are deliberately acted with a lack of emotion, with sparse dialogue. The gloomy soundtrack is good as well. These qualities are all effective, as they accentuates the unhappy nature of the characters.
This is a strange, sad flick about a group of people who cannot experience pleasure, and find ways to vicariously heighten their zest by enjoying a unique fetish revolving around bloody car accidents. These neurotic people try and rationalize their woeful lives, but by the film's end it becomes clear that they cannot be truly liberated from their distressed condition. Note how the (many) sex scenes are not remotely titillating, because the characters engage them in such a torpid manner. Even the car accidents are calm little smashes. Thematically, the film asks what gives us pleasure, and where is the line between pleasure and pain?
While it's interesting to ponder, in the end I was left with more of a love-hate feeling. The film waxes the artsy elements a too much and feels boring and redundant. Beating a dead horse is no fun, and there's many scenes that just seem to repeat each other. There is a lack of development and causes me to lose interest. About half of it is genuinely effective, but the rest is plodding. I know that's the point, but I think some more attentive work could have made it more effective in the end.
Labels:
car crashes,
david cronenberg,
james spader,
sex,
weird film
MUSIC REVIEW: Rush - Permanent Waves
"One of the best rock albums ever."
It is with Permanent Waves that Rush began to shed their progressive trappings and garner more interest beyond the steadfast progressive crowd. Geddy Lee began to sing at lower ranges, complexity was trimmed, but excellence was preserved. It is a precursor to Moving Pictures; a bridge between their recondite progressive rock days and their immersion in the mainstream. But while most transitional albums merit dismissal, Permanent Waves remains one of the band's best releases, accessible to the band's aficionados from their progressive era or their lush pop/rock days.
"Spirit of the Radio" and "Free Will," both recipients of lucrative radioplay, prove that songs can be commercially accessible without sacrifice. Neil Peart's superb lyrics lift "Spirit of the Radio" from a mere tribute to radio in Toronto to something markedly intelligent (he could always make something simple seem deep), and it features some of rock's most memorable guitar riffs. "Free Will" is an anthemic piece with inspiring individualist lyrics and an energizing solo by Lifeson.
Beyond the album's most recognizable songs, there's plenty of great material. "Entre Nous" is a love song with brains, all the better because it never uses the word love (all of the best love songs eschew the word, I find). "Different Strings," featuring some piano during the chorus, is a pretty song, and my favorite of the band's ballads. "Jacob's Ladder" is one of the band's most mysterious compositions. The stormy arrangement is dense, with swirls of synthesizers and fierce, chaotic riffs. The epic "Natural Science" is the closest thing to their previous epics, written in three movements and covering plenty of musical ground, from the enigmatic opening, to the futuristic-sounding mid-section, to the anthemic finale. It's as good as anything they ever wrote.
In the end, Permanent Waves is a rock milestone. A remarkable synthesis of progressive rock and commercial music, although there's nothing really commercial about it. Just great music, plain and simple.
MUSIC REVIEW: Rush - 2112
"Totally awesome rockin' prog and memorable sci-fi story of heroism."
2112 was an important album for Rush, because it combined with breadth of scope that they'd previously flirted with combined with tighter songcraft. Not to mention, absolutely memorable proto-prog-metal rockin' awesomeness. Up to this point, it was their best album. It was also their breakthrough record (well, comparatively speaking), and showed that lots of people would like a twenty minute epic if it was done so well.
2112 is NOT a concept album (a lot of people mistakenly label it as such). Anyone who says it is has the burden of showing how the title track is at all related to any of the other songs. Trust me, no such connection will be made unless you've hit the bong about 1000 times.
In any case, the big title track does tell a heroic story about one man who fights for individualism in a collective world. Ostensibly inspired by Ayn Rand's novella "Anthem," it uses a frightening sci-fi setting to tackle the good old debate of the individual vs. the collective. For the first time, the band writes an epic that seems about half as long as it really is, with inflections of driving riffery, soft acoustic moments, and virtuoso proficiency throughout. Reams of ear-catching riffs drench the "Overture," and the song progresses through its seven movements of rocking euphoria. This SOB is one of my favorite Rush songs ever, and it's the one that really got me turned onto the band.
The rest of the album is pretty good, but "2112" is what this disc is all about. A must own rock album.
MUSIC REVIEW: Rush - Hold Your Fire
"Attack of the 80s Part III."
Sure, the unequivocal 80s pop sound is evident here, like synth-soaked songs, the vocal stylings, and whatever else. That's not inherently bad news, however. You see, unlike most progressive rock bands, Rush fared well when the 80s sucked them in (Yes or Genesis, on the other hand, were turned to crap by the 80s). There is nothing tremendously distinctive about the songs themselves, other than the fact that the writing is very high caliber all throughout. Hold Your Fire is similar in sound to Power Windows, but it rocks a little less and shines a bit more often from track to track. I can empathize with the prog rockers who were PO'ed when Rush went in a very commercial direction, because it can be frustrating when a band goes through radical changes. I dig this record though. Neil Peart maintains his reputation as rock's best lyricist, while Lee's continued flirtations with synthesizers yields some effective results. Some people say "Damn you, Lee, drop the keyboards and pick up your bass guitar!" Cripes, listen to the album! It's full of dexterous bass playing, and combined with Peart's drumming it rounds out one of the best rhythm sections around. I kind of feel sorry for Lifeson, who is one of rock's most original guitarists but whose role on this album is diluted (although he provides an awesome solo on "Mission" and some vital energy on "Force Ten" that make that song so great, and some great ambient chords on "Tai Shan"... and lots of other cool parts, so whatever). Although I've never really warmed up to "Turn the Page," I dig this album... and this is from an overweening progressive rock fan. So, I give Hold Your Fire 5 stars.
MUSIC REVIEW: Marillion - Holidays in Eden
"Marillion goes pop and does it well."
Call me crazy, but I sincerely enjoy Holidays In Eden. I won't deny that it's commercially directed, a bit streamlined, but when the quality of the music is this good, who cares? This may be one of the few glowing reviews from a Marillion fan, but it deserves it. It is still characterized by good old Marillion attributes (awesome guitar solos, ambient arrangements, and lots of emotion), but it's diluted a bit by the pop endeavor.
Highlights include hook-laden "Cover My Eyes," with Hogarth showing off his deft vocal acrobatics, "Splintering Heart," a dramatic piece of classic Hogarth-Marillion (it's even a bit "Fishy"), the peppy title cut, and the radio friendly triad "No One Can," "Dry Land," and "Waiting To Happen." My favorite song would be "The Party," the moving story of a young girl who attends her first party (of the drugs, drinking, and promiscuous variety), and loses an element of her innocence as a result. A generic little idea that's made markedly compelling thanks to interesting lyrics and sad, atmospheric music. The final song, "100 Nights," also proves absorbing when given the attention ('cause it doesn't grab you right away). Under-appreciated, but many great things are.
Labels:
marillion,
neo-prog,
pop,
progressive rock,
Steve Hogarth
MUSIC REVIEW: Rush - Hemispheres
"Awesome Rush."
Rush's days of progressive rock hit their zenith with Hemispheres. It was big, bold, pretentious, orchestral...and it rocked. The incredible piece, "Cygnus X-1 Book II," proved that the band had mastered the epic format. Written in six movements, tied together by thematic unity, and telling the story of the philosophical conflict between reason and passion, it is possibly their best epic. Here, the band combines classical music's sense of space and monumental scope with rock's raw power and energy. The mixture of loud and soft passages and crescendos do more than add to the dynamics of the arrangement, but also perform well in translating the emotion of the composition, which is important given the song's philosophical overtones. Eighteen minutes never went by so fast...which is complimentary. It takes considerable skill not to make an epic seem long, and even more to make it seem short. This is especially laudable in Rush's case, since they don't have the added dimension through an emphasis on keyboards that most progressive bands have.
Side 2 of the album features two short songs and a 10 minute instrumental. The short songs are stronger than most that have preceded this album. "Circumstances" is a classic short Rush song (they have so many!), characterized by Lee's trademark shriek (really high on this one!), tight riffs and a great melody. "The Trees" is another favorite. A forest is used as a metaphor for socio-economic issues. Corny? Nope, just really smart. The serene interlude complements the natural setting, with some inventive percussion from Peart. "La Villa Strangiato" is what the band called "an exercise in self-indulgence." Ten minutes of awesome instrumental virtuosity that affirms the skill of the band. They say it's pompous, but the song is good enough that non-musicians can still appreciate it. Lifeson's guitar solo here is one of the all-time best Rush moments.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)